Post by drewlane on Aug 8, 2011 13:16:51 GMT -5
Personally, I have never read an article that have stirred such mixed emotions. I completely agree with Mr. W (who's name is very long, so we'll just call him Mr. W or Drew), but I feel he took the "solitude" aspect too deep into literary periods and religious values and ideas. The essay could have just been "the Web generation can't be alone." Everyone would have agreed. I have a horrible fear of loneliness, myself, and try to remedy it whenever possible. Mr. W made it seem like that fear was the end to a part of our person, but I don't necessarily think solitude is a better option over never being alone.
However, I don't think we have a fear of being alone, we just have a fear of having absolutely nothing to do. Anyone would rather watch paint dry over sit down, close your eyes, and be "alone". When the TV generation gets bored, they click on the TV to have something to do, to occupy their time. When the web generation has nothing to do, the switch on a PC, laptop, iPod, iPad, or phone and get on Facebook and Twitter. It is simply a mechanism of occupying our minds. Mr. W is on the right track, but I just don't think he even really interviewed a teenager or asked them what Facebook or Twitter is to them. It is not our God, as some would believe. It is just a way to, yes, stay connected, but more importantly, it is a way to give us something to do. The same goes for the TV generation. It is not their God, as the generation before them would likely say, it is a way to give them something to do.
Therefore, every generation has something that the previous did not and does not approve of. For the teenagers in the twenties, it was cars and music. The generation ahead of them thought it was awful and was ruling their lives. For the teenagers of the 70's and 80's the television came around and the adults thought it was going to ruin their lives. For the current generation, the internet has come about. The TV generation thinks it is going to rule our lives. I'm sure the web generation will find something they don't like about the future generations, too. I've just found that we keep writing articles about technology being a certain generations "God" when in reality, all generations have had something the previous did not, and article like Mr. W's are just more "generation discrimination".
I must say, however, that I did enjoy the points Mr. W made, and the article was very interesting. Although personally I don't know what to make of it, I did enjoy his in-depth analysis of the dissapearance of solitude. I look forward to seeing if his analyses are correct!
However, I don't think we have a fear of being alone, we just have a fear of having absolutely nothing to do. Anyone would rather watch paint dry over sit down, close your eyes, and be "alone". When the TV generation gets bored, they click on the TV to have something to do, to occupy their time. When the web generation has nothing to do, the switch on a PC, laptop, iPod, iPad, or phone and get on Facebook and Twitter. It is simply a mechanism of occupying our minds. Mr. W is on the right track, but I just don't think he even really interviewed a teenager or asked them what Facebook or Twitter is to them. It is not our God, as some would believe. It is just a way to, yes, stay connected, but more importantly, it is a way to give us something to do. The same goes for the TV generation. It is not their God, as the generation before them would likely say, it is a way to give them something to do.
Therefore, every generation has something that the previous did not and does not approve of. For the teenagers in the twenties, it was cars and music. The generation ahead of them thought it was awful and was ruling their lives. For the teenagers of the 70's and 80's the television came around and the adults thought it was going to ruin their lives. For the current generation, the internet has come about. The TV generation thinks it is going to rule our lives. I'm sure the web generation will find something they don't like about the future generations, too. I've just found that we keep writing articles about technology being a certain generations "God" when in reality, all generations have had something the previous did not, and article like Mr. W's are just more "generation discrimination".
I must say, however, that I did enjoy the points Mr. W made, and the article was very interesting. Although personally I don't know what to make of it, I did enjoy his in-depth analysis of the dissapearance of solitude. I look forward to seeing if his analyses are correct!